Connect with us

New York Giants

Can we trust New York Giants brass to get QB decision right?

At the 2004 NFL Draft, former general manager Ernie Accorsi built a decision that significantly impacted the New York Giants franchise.

Accorsi’s gamble on quarterback Eli Manning continues to pay out dividends for the New York Giants to this day. And current GM Dave Gettleman and head mentor Pat Shurmur appear to be intent on riding the very same horse as prolonged as humanly possible.

Let there be no doubt that having Manning as a protection web, gave Gettleman and business self confidence that the G-Adult males could grab working back again Saquon Barkley, and then make a possible playoff operate in 2018.

In spite of what team brass said for the duration of and immediately after the earlier year, no a person brings in the likes of left tackle Nate Solder, linebacker Kareem Martin, edge defender Connor Barwin, working back again Jonathan Stewart and guard Patrick Omameh with the clear intention of securing a 5-11 file.

Component of the attraction about retaining the “Manning protection net” arrives from the fact that he’s a acknowledged quantity. Plainly, Manning at 38-decades outdated stays a better choice than Davis Webb, Kyle Lauletta or any of the 2019 quarterback class. Continuity accounts for a little something, but around the earlier several decades, there has also been dwindling return on the Manning investment.

For case in point, you can get a person per cent amount of return on a savings account, or 7 per cent if you consider the very same cash and position it in shares or mutual resources. The savings account has no hazard, and negligible return, while shares have the probability of bigger return, but occur with hazard.

There you have the central theme between using Sam Darnold vs . having the Saquon Barkley/Eli Manning tandem very last year.

It is common hazard vs . safety.

Statistically, around the earlier couple of seasons, a circumstance can and will be built for retaining Manning. But part of his that needs bigger scrutiny is his get-decline file, which stands at 116-114 according to Professional Football Target.

When Gettleman was marketing supporters and media on the Barkley variety, and Trader Dave did that routinely in draft’s operate up, he also built veiled references to the 2018 quarterback class.

Creating himself slide in like with a player practically absolutely was aimed at USC’s Sam Darnold in specific. Given that that time, Gettleman tried to participate in revisionist background now and he clarifies that the Giants’ selection of Barkley was no reflection on the quarterback class.

Not genuine, based mostly upon his individual terms. But that was then, and he no for a longer time has to “sell” the notion of drafting Barkley. Heck, he’s the AP Rookie-of-the-Calendar year.

Very last draft, Gettleman also perpetuated one more seemingly minimal-hazard, high-reward manuever for which former GM Jerry Reese was popular. He grabbed quarterback Kyle Lauletta in the fourth-spherical. Upon drafting the former Richmond Spider, everyone said the proper matters. Immediately after all, Lauletta was the Senior Bowl MVP.

 (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Photographs)

Yet hunting at Lauletta’s pre-draft scouting report, really should have been an eye opener. In addition, if you subscribe to the “it’s only a fourth-spherical pick” idea, then how would have Da’Shawn Hand, Nick Nelson, Kenny Young or Dorance Armstrong glance in Massive Blue?

At greatest, Lauletta is a marginal NFL prospect, and at worst, he’ll be a wasted draft pick for a team that could have used young defensive aid. No volume of NFL coaching can or will make up for a talent deficit.

Expertise evaluators and coaches make this slip-up at every solitary stage of athletics.

When it arrives to the quarterback placement, there is constantly inherent hazard. Even the good New York Giants general manager George Young whiffed on Dave Brown in 1992. It occurs.

This year’s quarterback class consists of Kyler Murray (Oklahoma), Dwayne Haskins (Ohio Condition), Drew Lock (Missouri) and Daniel Jones (Duke). Both Will Grier (West Virginia) and Ryan Finley (NC Condition) aren’t very likely to crack the initially-spherical, but they will be drafted, very likely in the initially a few rounds.

All it takes is a person club, a person general manager or a person owner to slide in like with a quarterback talent. The place are Tim Tebow, Josh Freeman, Brady Quinn, Vince Young, Matt Leinert or Christian Ponder proper now?

But you most likely have to kiss some frogs in order to locate the prince.

By not using Darnold very last yr, Gettleman set extra strain on himself this yr for a person easy reason. If he was not in like with Darnold, how can he be in like with Haskins? Or Murray? Or Jones?

It is a issue that the veteran NFL executive will have to answer as he ponders the up coming significant phase in the future of the New York Giants. Unless of course Gettleman believes that Manning can participate in endlessly, he will have to consider a hazard sooner or later.




Source Link

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in New York Giants